Cover image for Identity in Conflict: The Struggle between Esau and Jacob, Edom and Israel By Elie Assis

Identity in Conflict

The Struggle between Esau and Jacob, Edom and Israel

Elie Assis

BUY

$47.50 | Hardcover Edition
ISBN: 978-1-57506-417-8

224 pages
6" × 9"
2016

Siphrut: Literature and Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures

Identity in Conflict

The Struggle between Esau and Jacob, Edom and Israel

Elie Assis

No nation has been subjected to a wider range of biblical attitudes and emotions than Edom. In some sources, Edom is perceived as Israel’s brother; in many others, the animosity toward Edom is tremendous. The book of Genesis introduces Isaac, his wife Rebecca, and their twin sons, Esau and Jacob. Rivalry between the brothers emerges even before their birth and escalates over the course of their lives. The question of which son should be favored also causes tension in the parents’ relationship, and most of the Genesis text concerning Isaac and Rebecca revolves around this issue. The narrative describes the fraternal conflict between Jacob and Esau at length, and many hold that this description is a reflection of the hostility between Edom and Israel. However, the relationship between the brothers is not always depicted as strained.

 

  • Description
  • Table of Contents
No nation has been subjected to a wider range of biblical attitudes and emotions than Edom. In some sources, Edom is perceived as Israel’s brother; in many others, the animosity toward Edom is tremendous. The book of Genesis introduces Isaac, his wife Rebecca, and their twin sons, Esau and Jacob. Rivalry between the brothers emerges even before their birth and escalates over the course of their lives. The question of which son should be favored also causes tension in the parents’ relationship, and most of the Genesis text concerning Isaac and Rebecca revolves around this issue. The narrative describes the fraternal conflict between Jacob and Esau at length, and many hold that this description is a reflection of the hostility between Edom and Israel. However, the relationship between the brothers is not always depicted as strained.

The twofold relationship between the brothers in Genesis—brotherhood and fraternity coupled with hatred and rivalry—introduces a dichotomy that is retained throughout the Hebrew Bible. In this monograph, Assis elucidates the complex relationship between Edom and Israel reflected in the Bible, to attempt to clarify the source of this complexity and the function that this relationship serves in the various biblical texts and Israel’s early history. He shows how this relationship plays an important role in the formation of Israel’s identity, and how the historical interaction between the nations influenced the people’s theological conception, as reflected in prophetic literature, poetry, and biblical narrative.

1. “Esau Jacob’s Brother”: Israel and Edom are Brothers

2. Jacob and Esau in the Book of Genesis

3. Israel and Edom in the Preexilic Biblical Literature

4. “But Esau I Despised”: Israel and Edom are Enemies

5. Jeremiah’s Prophecy against Edom: Chapter 49

6. Ezekiel’s Prophecy against Edom (25:12–14)

7. Ezekiel’s Prophecy against Edom, Chapter 35

8. Isaiah’s Prophecy against Edom, Chapter 34

9. Isaiah’s Prophecy against Edom, Chapter 63

10. Obadiah’s Prophecy against Edom

11. The Prophecy of Malachi, 1:2–5

12. The Anti-Edomite Ideology of the Genealogical Lists in 1 Chronicles 1

13. Edom and Israel in Rabbinic and Medieval Literature

Afterword

Bibliography

Mailing List

Subscribe to our mailing list and be notified about new titles, journals and catalogs.